Chirality as a hidden property
Chirality entered the project because Professor Wu’s research group at SUTD does extensive research in chiral metasurfaces and chiral light-matter interactions, and she always encourages the team to exchange ideas across different research topics and explore interdisciplinary opportunities. Inspired by the work on chiral metasurfaces, the researchers wondered: Can chirality also become an important degree of freedom in free-electron radiation?
“We noticed that many of the previous approaches to chiral Smith-Purcell relied on specially designed metasurfaces or photonic structures to generate or control chirality,” says Zhu. “By contrast, the chirality of conventional Smith-Purcell radiation itself hadn’t been explored.”
One reason is because Smith-Purcell radiation has traditionally been understood largely through a two-dimensional (2D) picture. “In this picture, we typically consider the plane containing electron trajectory,” he says. “Within this plane, the emitted radiation is linearly polarized. This led to a long-standing belief that conventional Smith-Purcell radiation is essentially linearly polarized.”
So the team decided to go back to the simplest system and ask: What happens if we look at conventional Smith-Purcell radiation in the full three-dimensional (3D) space? To do it, they built a simple 3D model of an electron traveling above a conventional grating, without introducing any chiral metasurface or specially designed chiral geometry. The result? Not one they expected.
“Looking beyond the conventional electron plane, we discovered the radiation wasn’t simply linearly polarized,” says Zhu. “Instead, left- and right-circularly polarized components naturally appeared in different regions of the 3D radiation pattern. In the symmetric system, these opposite chiral components are distributed symmetrically. In the conventional symmetry plane, their handedness balances out, leaving linearly polarized radiation. In other words: Chirality wasn’t absent—it was hidden by the symmetry and the conventional way in which Smith-Purcell radiation had been viewed.”
The best part of the discovery? “Our first reaction was definitely surprise and excitement when the 3D simulations showed clear left- and right-circularly polarized components within a system that was completely achiral,” Zhu says. “It wasn’t what we expected based on a conventional picture of Smith-Purcell radiation.”
But when a simulation contradicts your intuition, excitement is quickly chased by skepticism. “Before trying to explain the result, we repeatedly checked it using different simulation tools and different models,” he says. “The same chiral radiation pattern consistently appeared, so we became convinced it was a genuine physical effect rather than a numerical artefact.”
Then came a deeper question: Where does the chirality come from if neither the grating nor the overall structure is chiral? “We began looking for the physical origin and, through further literature research and theoretical analysis, connected the phenomenon to the transverse spin angular momentum carried by the electron’s evanescent field,” Zhu says. “The grating converts this spin to be converted into the longitudinal spin of the emitted photons.”
It was a real ‘aha!’ moment for the team because they realized the grating wasn’t creating chirality from scratch. “The chirality was already encoded within the electron’s evanescent field, and the Smith-Purcell process was revealing it in the emitted light. Once we understood this, the next step became quite natural,” he says. “If left- and right-handed components are already present but balanced because of symmetry, then breaking this symmetry should allow one handedness to dominate. This led us to explore simple symmetry-breaking approaches, such as twisting the electron trajectory relative to the grating or introducing a lateral displacement. By doing so, we can transform the hidden chirality into a net chiral emission and control its handedness.”
Time to rethink role of electrons in free-electron photonics
What does the group’s work mean for photonics? At the fundamental level, “our results expand the picture of Smith-Purcell radiation,” says Zhu. “Historically, Smith-Purcell radiation was discussed mainly in terms of wavelength, emission angle, and intensity. Our work shows polarization and chirality are also intrinsic degrees of freedom of this radiation—even in a simple, achiral system.”
This suggests it’s time to rethink the role of the electron in free-electron photonics. “A moving electron isn’t simply a broadband excitation source,” he explains. “Its electromagnetic near field has a rich vectorial structure and carries properties such as transverse spin angular momentum, which can be transferred into emitted photons through interaction with a photonic structure.”
It also suggests a different design philosophy for chiral free-electron emission. “Many previous approaches focused on engineering sophisticated metasurfaces or resonant photonic structures to create or manipulate chirality,” Zhu says. “The results show that another possibility is to start from the intrinsic spin properties of the electron field itself and use relatively simple symmetry breaking to access and control them.”
And this idea may extend beyond Smith-Purcell radiation, which is only one of the many mechanisms through which the electromagnetic field of a free electron can be converted into light. “Since the transverse spin originates from the electron’s evanescent field rather than from the grating itself, it’s natural to ask whether similar hidden chiral or spin-dependent properties may also exist in other free-electron radiation mechanisms,” Zhu says. “In this sense, our work provides a new understanding of Smith-Purcell radiation and also motivation to revisit other well-known free-electron emission processes from a full 3D and vectorial perspective.”
Many of these mechanisms have been studied for decades, but their polarization and spin degrees of freedom may still contain overlooked physics.
“It can be useful for free-electron light sources because polarization control doesn’t need to be tied to a specific optical resonance,” says Zhu. “It offers a way to combine chirality with one of the major advantages of free-electron radiation: Broad spectral tunability.”

